什麼力量推動中國創造奇蹟？外國網友這樣説！_風聞

近期有不少機構都對2019年全年，中國經濟實際增速做了預測。比如，惠譽評級機構預測，2019年和2020年中國的GDP實際增速或將放緩到6.1%。

清華大學主導的《中國宏觀經濟分析與預測報告》認為，今年中國經濟增長6.3%；

交通銀行金融研究中心發佈《2019年中國宏觀經濟金融展望》報告中也認為今年實際增長6.3%。

聯合國、IMF等機構在之前的預測報告中也預測2019年中國經濟或將實際增長6.3%，2019年中國GDP可能達到14.22萬億美元，繼續穩居世界第二大經濟體！

毫無疑問，這樣的經濟預測引發了世界網友的巨大討論：

是什麼力量使得僅僅就在20年前GDP總量僅為1.09萬億美元的中國，在短短20年內實現13連番，從世界第7上升至世界第二？

1、Manoj Debbarma

In China there is no religion and politics that’’s why they are developed ok

為何？因為在中國，沒有宗教和政治，所以發展才好。

2、Akshaya Mohanty

Manoj Debbarma hahahaha they read their true history not british made bootlicking history which glorifies invaders and narrates how invaders made a country rich china dont do unwatnted westernisation of their culture Chinese are sweetly more asian then overmixed cultural peoppe of india

哈哈哈哈，他們能閲讀真正的歷史，而不是不列顛製造的阿諛奉承的、讚美入侵者/敍述入侵者如何讓一個國家富有的歷史。中國沒有做西方想要他們喪失自我文化的行為，中國人更像亞洲人，而不是文化太過繁雜的印度人。

3、Scion of Ikshvaku

Lol.. USA, Israel stand ahead of India in terms of importance of religion. Still they’’re far advance then India and China , ur logic is completely bullshit, Religion plays an important role in Humanity, in philosophy, in well being of human. Israel surrounded by hostile neighbours, with high population density, with no Arurable land , No water , just a desert land has made impossible things possible.

哈哈哈，美國、以色列在宗教重要性方面領先印度。他們仍然比印度和中國先進得多，你的邏輯完全是扯淡，宗教在人性、哲學和人類福祉中扮演着重要角色。以色列被敵對的鄰國包圍，人口密度高，沒有可耕種的土地，沒有水，只有一片沙漠，這一切使得不可能的事情成為可能。他們祈禱，他們崇拜，他們學習，他們創新，他們努力工作。

The Jews they prays , they worship , they learns , they Innovates, they works hard. Israelis are excellent in every field , they are not like Communist goon China , who steals Technology from Other Countries, makes Copycats, China just has 1 party system that’’s why they takes decision effectively, where as in india the Fake NGO’’s, Activists, Opposition’’s all tries their level best to dismantle our Country. So stfu

以色列人在每個領域都是優秀的,他們不像中國——山寨,中國只有一種聲音，這就是為何他們能高效決策的原因，而印度則充斥着各種虛假的NGO，活動家，反對派，他們都試圖拆散我們的國家。所以你閉嘴吧你。

4、patil rakesh

Ignorance! What do you know?because there is stable government, no more discuss political ,only focosed on innovation and technologies, more practical knowledge than theory knowledge,no caste regions,only talk on development,strick action etc become china powerful

無知，你又知道什麼？因為有一個穩定的政府，不討論政治，只專注於創新和技術，更多的實踐知識比理論知識，沒有種姓地區，只有談論發展，強硬的行動等，才讓中國強大！

It needs a dynamic vision to see the problem. I am a Frenchman. In the past 20 years, I have personally felt the growing influence of China. The commercial products that once made us proud are constantly being replaced by those made in China. Germany, Britain and France have been unable to compete with China directly. Next, it’s the United States. Although it seems to be very strong now, but 20 years later?

看到問題需要一個動態的眼光，我是一個法國人，最近20年的時間我親身感受到了中國影響力的日趨壯大，曾經讓我們驕傲的商業產品正不斷地被中國製造所取代，德國、英國、法國已經無法與中國直接競爭，接下來輪到美國了，雖然他現在看來還很強大，但是20年後呢？

5、Akshay Thakor

Aha, you are very objective. I like objective people, not ignorant people who are blinded by the false news of hatred. China has made great achievements indeed!

啊哈，你很客觀。我喜歡客觀的人，而不是被仇恨的假消息矇蔽雙眼的無知的人。中國確實取得了巨大成就！

In my opinion, the reasons for China’s success are summarized as follows:

我認為，中國成功的原因概括如下：

1 Population control、2 Skilled education、3 fast and maintain Transport、4 infrastructure、5 large scale Manufacturing 、6 Free economic Zone& businesses Zone

1.控制人口、2.技能培訓、3.快速通勤體系、4.基礎設施、5.大規模製造、6.自由經濟區、商業區

6、cerci tao

you are right. But as an Indian, you need to remind you that you forget the most important point. They have the most efficient government in the world. In India, the construction period of a bridge is usually 8 years, but in China, it may only take 6 months!

你説得對。但是作為一個印度人需要提醒你，你忘記了最重要的一點，他們擁有全世界最為高效的政府，在印度，一座大橋的建設週期通常為8年，但是在中國，這個時間或許只需要6個月！

7、Saitan ka Sala

Yes, their efficient government and strong ability to act are the key to success. Of course, China also has the largest labor quality population in the world. I can guarantee that if other countries, especially large population countries such as India, simply copy the Chinese model roughly, they will surely fail!

是的，他們高效的政府和強大的行動能力是成功的關鍵。當然，中國也是世界上勞動質量人口最多的國家。我可以保證，如果其他國家，特別是像印度這樣的人口大國，簡單地照搬中國的模式，他們一定會失敗的！

8、ekanth babu r j

I admire China’s great achievements and respect its hard-working people, but as an Indian, I’m curious, why can’t we copy China’s success model? They succeed, which proves the rationality of this model. I think we should copy it and then continue to succeed.

我欽佩中國的偉大成就，尊重中國的勤勞人民，但作為印度人，我很好奇，為什麼我們不能效仿中國的成功模式？他們成功了，證明了這種模式的合理性。我認為我們應該複製它然後繼續成功。

9、Saitan ka Sala

My Indian friend, I said this sentence without any offensive meaning. I just stated my own point of view: India can’t simply and roughly copy China’s model. In my opinion, the reasons are various, from the quality of population and labor, traditional culture and even national thinking.

我的印度朋友，我説這句話沒有任何冒犯的意思。我只是闡述了自己的觀點：印度不能簡單粗暴地照搬中國的模式。在我看來，原因是多方面的，從人口素質和勞動素質、傳統文化乃至民族思想等方面。

We need to know that the collective consciousness of the Chinese people formed in the Mao Zedong era is extremely strong. They advocate and sincerely accept the “dedication”, which is very unusual in India. Then there is a low illiteracy rate, which is not achievable in a day. In addition, I think there is a special thing in Chinese culture, which makes the general Chinese people have a kind of detachment from themselves “Sense of mission”.

要知道中國人在毛時代所形成的集體意識是極為強大的，他們倡導並衷心的接受“奉獻精神”，這在印度是很不常見的，然後是低文盲率，這不是一天可以達到的，除此以外，我認為中國的文化中存在一種特別的東西，那使得一般的中國人都具有一種超脱自我的“使命感”。

10、ekanth babu r j

Well, thank you for your reminding. Although I don’t want to admit it, it’s true. Too many people around us emphasize their own interests too much and are afraid of hardship and laziness. But I believe that with the popularization of education, everything will change.

好吧，謝謝你的提醒。雖然我不想承認，但這是真的。我們周圍太多的人過於強調自己的利益，害怕吃苦和懶惰。但我相信隨着教育的普及，一切都會改變。

11、Ohm namah Shivay

China is so progressive and really has changed the way world used to look at China . Focussed and all round development with good standard of living for its people. Really commendable。

中國是如此進步，真的改變了世界看待中國的方式。注重全面發展，提高人民生活水平。真正值得稱讚。

12、Spring in Osaka

China has their own Google, Facebook, Amazon, Microsoft,

中國有他們自己的谷歌、臉書、亞馬遜和微軟。

I have to say, as a Japanese, I really feel jealous of many times. Of course, it is not the kind of hatred that is a complaint about the unfortunate fate of my country. Just 30 years ago, everything was so beautiful, but we lost everything because of the economic bubble.

不得不説，作為一個日本人，我很多時候真的感到很嫉妒，當然，不是那種憎惡，是一種對自己國家不幸命運的埋怨，僅僅就在30年前，我們的一切還這麼美好，但是因為經濟泡沫，我們錯失了一切！

13、Manoj Debbarma

Don’t complain, Japanese friends. I have to say that you are really an excellent nation. I like your cameras and TV plays very much. But for some reasons in the past, as a defeated country in World War II, it will be subject to various restrictions of the United States, but what about that? only blame your parents for choosing the wrong path。

不要抱怨了，日本朋友，不得不説你們確實是一個優秀的民族，我很喜歡你們的攝像機和電視劇，但是因為過去的一些原因，作為二戰的戰敗國，會受到美國的各種限制，不過那又怎麼樣呢？只能怪你們的父輩選擇了錯誤的道路。

14、Spring in Osaka

That’s all the history of the past. What does it have to do with us? Is it wrong that we don’t want to invade anyone and live like a normal country?

那都是過去的歷史了，和我們有什麼關係呢？我們現在並沒有想去侵略任何人，只想像個正常的國家一樣的生活，難道有錯嗎？

15、Manoj Debbarma

I don’t think it’s necessary to discuss. It seems that you still don’t realize your mistakes? A murderer said, “I killed yesterday. What does it have to do with me today?”? I just want to live like a normal person.

我覺得沒必要討論。你好像還沒意識到自己的錯誤？一個殺人犯説：“昨天的我殺了人。跟今天的我有什麼關係？”？我只想像正常人一樣生活。

16、krishna kishor

I’’m from NorthEast ASSAM.Our ancestors came from Yunnan province,China.Best wishes for Chinese future。China is developing successfully because their leaders are competent, productive and long term thinkers。Yes we should be prepared like them

我來自東北邦，我們的祖先來自中國雲南省。對中國未來致以最良好的祝願。中國的發展之所以成功，是因為他們的領導人有能力、有生產力、有遠見。是的，我們應該準備好像他們那樣（發展）。

17、krishna kishor

Mobile phone was not available for normal public, especially the smart phone s, but China made it easy！

普通大眾原本無法使用手機，尤其是智能手機，但中國讓獲取手機變得容易了！

I like Xiaomi mobile phone. It’s so easy to use!

我喜歡小米手機，實在太好用了！

18、Alisa honey

right, unlike the high price of Apple Mobile, millet mobile from China is the best choice for young people in India. Its price is not too expensive, but its performance is not far behind. Every millet sales meeting will set off a climax in India!

沒錯，與蘋果手機高昂的價格不同，來自中國的小米手機簡直就是印度年輕人的最好選擇，他的價格不算太貴，但是性能並不差距多少，每一次的小米法發售會，都會在印度掀起一次次的高潮！

19、my creations

Now 2019 India’’s GDP growth was down from 2% GDP growth of India in 2019 is 5% aur 5.8% in present day！Are you still in the mood to discuss China’s mobile phones here? I really feel extremely disappointed!

現在印度2019年的國內生產總值增長已經下降了2%，現在只有5%了！你竟然還有心情在這裏討論中國的手機？我真的感到極度失望！

20、kishan gupta

Why not? China is the real player on the world stage. Why do we always compare with them? Life in India is very happy now, at least I think we are all moving in a good direction!People like you will never get happiness, because you always pursue something unrealistic and not your own, and then complain constantly。

為什麼不呢？中國才是世界舞台的真正玩家，為什麼我們總是要去和他們進行比較？印度現在的生活已經十分幸福了，至少我認為我們的一切都在朝好的方向發展！你這種人永遠不會得到幸福，因為你總是去追求一些不切實際和不屬於自己的東西，然後就是不斷地抱怨。

Believe me, if you look through the history, you will find that in the history, except for the Peacock Dynasty more than 2000 years ago, we are basically in a state of laxity. But after 2000 years, we are still so happy. Isn’t that good?

相信我，如果你翻閲歷史就會發現，我們在歷史上除了兩千多年前的孔雀王朝，其他時候基本上就處於一種放鬆的狀態，不過2000多年了，我們依舊如此的幸福，這樣不好嗎？

毫無疑問，對於印度網友“kishan gupta ”的言論，老鐵是表示一百個支持的。

無他，人民的幸福永遠是第一位的，至於世界舞台上的那些糟心事，自然留給一些“真正的玩家”去傷腦筋好了，畢竟，總是去追求一些不切實際和不屬於自己的東西，所帶來的必然是無盡的抱怨….